Mobley v. Workday Explained
Where Mobley v. Workday stands as of November 2026, what the court has held on AI vendor liability, and what to ask your ATS vendor.
By the HireRabbit.AI team · Published · Last updated

On this page
This article is general information, not legal advice. No order in this ongoing case finds that anyone discriminated. Check any change to your process with employment counsel.
Mobley v. Workday is a federal lawsuit in the Northern District of California claiming that AI screening tools Workday provides to employers discriminated against job applicants. The court has not decided whether that is true. It has ruled that the claims can go forward on the theory that a vendor can be liable under federal anti-discrimination law as the employer's agent.
As of November 3, 2026, the case is pending. More than 15,000 people have opted into the age discrimination collective, the plaintiffs moved for class certification on September 14, 2026, and Workday's opposition is due November 10. There has been no ruling on the merits, no settlement and no trial date.
Timeline of the case
The case is No. 3:23-cv-00770-RFL, before Judge Rita F. Lin. Dates come from the court's orders, except the first row (the EEOC's amicus brief) and the filing month (secondary reporting).
| Date | What happened |
|---|---|
| June 2021 | Mobley files a charge of discrimination with the EEOC. |
| February 2023 | Mobley files the lawsuit against Workday. |
| July 12, 2024 | Agent theory and disparate impact claims proceed; employment agency theory and intentional discrimination claims dismissed. |
| May 16, 2025 | The court preliminarily certifies a collective under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA). |
| July 29, 2025 | The collective is held to cover HiredScore AI features (Spotlight and Fetch). |
| January 6, 2026 | Three plaintiffs join, adding Title VII sex discrimination and California FEHA claims. |
| March 6, 2026 | ADEA disparate impact claims by applicants reaffirmed; FEHA claims dismissed with leave to amend. |
| June 22, 2026 | FEHA claims and one ADA claim survive; a race claim is dismissed and the direct employer theory is struck. |
| The figure of 1.1 billion rejected applications came from Workday's own 2025 opposition brief, where Workday used it to argue that the collective would be too large. It is not a finding by the court. |
What the court has held so far
A vendor can be the employer's agent
In the July 12, 2024 order, Judge Lin accepted that Workday's customers allegedly "delegate traditional hiring functions, including rejecting applicants, to the algorithmic decision-making tools provided by Workday." On those allegations, the software "is not simply implementing in a rote way the criteria that employers set forth, but is instead participating in the decision-making process."
That is the agent theory. A vendor whose tool carries out hiring functions the employer has handed over can face liability alongside the employer under federal laws including Title VII and the ADEA. The court did not say any particular vendor is an agent, only that these allegations were enough to proceed.
Not every software vendor is an agent
The court drew a limit: "many software vendors do not qualify as agents." Its examples were a spreadsheet that sorts applicants by birthdate and an email provider that sends rejections. Neither is "participating in the determination of which employees to hire." It is a line drawn at the pleading stage, not a safe harbor.
Theories the court rejected
The court rejected the EEOC's employment agency theory, holding that screening is "not sufficient to allege that Workday 'procures' employees," and dismissed it without leave to amend. In June 2026 it struck the theory that Workday is liable as a direct employer.
Disparate impact claims proceed, intent claims do not
The intentional discrimination claims were dismissed in July 2024, but the disparate impact claims survived.
The ADEA part has a known weak point: the Seventh Circuit (Kleber) and the Eleventh (Villarreal) have ruled that the ADEA does not cover disparate impact claims by job applicants. Judge Lin reaffirmed in March 2026 that it does and, in July 2026, declined to send the question up early, so it can be appealed only after the case ends.
Who is in the age collective
The collective turns on a "denied recommendation": Workday's AI scored, sorted, ranked or screened the applicant, the result was not a recommendation to hire, and it either went to the employer or was an automatic rejection. People scored only on criteria the employer itself selected are excluded.
California law can make the vendor directly liable
California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) claims survived in June 2026, on allegations that the tools were designed and operated from California. Citing Raines v. U.S. Healthworks (2023), the court held that Workday can be directly liable for its own FEHA-regulated activities "on the employer's behalf," whether or not its customers are liable.
The same order kept one plaintiff's ADA claim alive on the theory that screening criteria can act as proxies for health conditions.
What it means for employers
The case names only Workday, but its rulings land on employers too. What follows are our recommendations, not the court's.
The agent theory adds the vendor as a possible defendant; it does not take the employer out. The decisions are still your hiring decisions. Our AI hiring laws guide covers the state and city rules on top of this.
Know what each tool is doing
The orders draw one line repeatedly: a tool that applies, "in a rote way," criteria the employer chose, versus a tool that produces its own recommendations and rejections. A tool that applies your criteria faithfully still reproduces any bias in them.
Know, feature by feature, whether a score comes from criteria you set or from a model the vendor designed. The explainable AI resume screening guide covers what to look for.
Bias testing results may be discoverable
The May 28, 2026 discovery ruling split Workday's bias testing in two. Attorney-directed testing on Candidate Skills Match was held privileged. The 2023 testing of HiredScore Spotlight, shared with an outside consultant using the NYC Local Law 144 impact-ratio method, was not.
The lesson is not to avoid testing. Decide with counsel, before you start, who directs it and who sees the results. Our guide to adverse impact analysis for resume screening covers how to run the numbers on your own funnel.
Customer data and subpoenas
Workday was ordered to list the customers that enabled the HiredScore features, and the plaintiffs have subpoenaed 35 customers. The magistrate judge held, and Judge Lin upheld in July 2026, that Workday does not "control" applicant data held in customer tenants under its Master Subscription Agreement.
If your ATS holds applicant data in your own tenant, requests for it may come to you even when you are not a party.
The EEOC is stepping back
Federal enforcement has moved away from disparate impact since 2025. The EEOC's National Enforcement Plan, signed June 4, 2026, says the agency "will not commence, develop or continue to pursue disparate impact litigation," according to Cooley's summary. On October 16, 2026, it sent a final rule rescinding the interpretive parts of the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures for regulatory review, Ogletree reported.
None of this amends Title VII or the ADEA, so private suits like Mobley continue. The FEHA claims in Mobley rest on California law.
Questions to ask your ATS vendor
- Can we switch each AI feature on and off? The collective in Mobley turns on which features a customer enabled.
- Are your scores sent to us, and can they reject anyone automatically? That is the "denied recommendation" test.
- Are scores built only from criteria we select? This is the line the court drew.
- Who holds our applicant data, and who can access it?
- Do you bias-test, using what method, and will you share the results?
- What independent audits exist? Ask for the audit itself and its date, not a summary.
What to keep on your side
- The criteria and weights for each role, with the date and who agreed them. The job description guide shows how to turn these into a scoring sheet.- A written reason for each single-candidate decision, as our guide to documenting hiring decisions explains.
- Adverse impact results on your own funnel, and a map of the applicant data in your tenant.
How this maps to HireRabbit.AI
HireRabbit.AI scores each resume in four visible areas (skills, experience, projects and education) and builds the overall score from them. Its AI sets the area weights from the job description; the weights add up to 100 and stay the same for every applicant.
Auto-reject runs only below the team's cut-off, in a batch a person confirms, and it can be reversed. The how scoring works page walks through the mechanics.
None of that removes legal risk. The area scores come from our model, not only from criteria you select, so the vendor questions above apply to us too.