Reference Checks That Tell You Something
What research says about reference checks, why most calls tell you little, and how to run structured, consented checks, with a sample script.
By the HireRabbit.AI team · Published · Last updated

On this page
- What the research says about reference checks
- Why most reference calls tell you nothing
- How to structure reference checks
- Consent and legal care
- Backchannel references and their risks
- References as a fraud check in remote hiring
- Worked example: a customer success manager script
- How this maps to HireRabbit.AI
Most reference checks end the same way. The recruiter calls two people the candidate picked, hears that she was "great to work with", ticks a box and sends the offer. Or the former employer's HR team confirms her title and dates and nothing more.
Reference checks can do better, given the discipline you would put into an interview. This guide covers the research, why most calls are empty, how to structure them, consent, backchannel references, fraud checks and a sample script.
What the research says about reference checks
In their 1998 summary of 85 years of selection research, Frank Schmidt and John Hunter put the validity of reference checks for predicting job performance at .26. That is well below structured interviews (.51) and work sample tests (.54), but above years of job experience (.18). Added to a general mental ability test, reference checks raised the combined validity from .51 to .57.
The authors flagged a problem with their own number. The studies behind it predate the current US legal climate, and by 1998 many past employers would confirm only dates of employment and job titles, not quality of work or whether the person quit or was dismissed.
When Paul Sackett and colleagues revised these estimates in 2022, they excluded reference checks for insufficient information. There is no modern, corrected figure to quote.
What the evidence does support is structure. The US Office of Personnel Management (OPM) says reference checks can add predictive value on top of other measures, and that adding structure, as with interviews, can make them more effective. That means questions based on a job analysis and the same questions for every applicant.
Why most reference calls tell you nothing
Three things drain the value out of a typical call:
- The candidate picks the referees. People choose colleagues who like them. The US Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB), in its 2005 report on reference checking, notes that a referee suggested by another referee is "not directly motivated to cast the applicant in a positive light".
- Policies limit what employers say. MSPB observes that HR staff at a former employer can usually verify only basic employment information. Some former supervisors are also bound by "clean record" settlement agreements.
- The questions are vague. "Would you rehire her?" invites a polite yes. MSPB found that unstructured, inconsistent reference checks may not produce useful information.
MSPB also describes hiring officials who have grown attached to a finalist and soften the questions that might spoil the hire.
How to structure reference checks
A structured reference check is a short interview with a different witness, built from the same materials as your interview loop.
Tie every question to the scorecard
Start from the competencies on your structured interview scorecard. MSPB suggests building reference questions from the structured interview questions used in the same hiring process. Pick two or three where interview evidence was thin or a referee watched the work for months, rather than repeating what other steps measured well.
Ask for behavior, not adjectives
Ask what the candidate did in a specific situation and what happened next. "Tell me about a time she handled an upset customer" gets an account you can rate. "Is she good with customers?" gets "yes".
Use the same core questions for every finalist
MSPB recommends a standard set of questions for each vacancy, asked of every referee, so information is comparable across applicants. It advises against one fixed list for all jobs, because such lists get shared and make coaching referees easier.
Set the number of calls in advance too. OPM estimates about 20 minutes per structured phone check and recommends at least three contacts.
Choose referees who saw the work
MSPB cites a rule of thumb: the referee and applicant should have worked together for at least six months within the last five years. Supervisors are usually the strongest source, because they have watched and appraised the work.
Tell every candidate the same standard upfront, such as "two people who managed you and one peer from your last two roles".
Write notes during the call and rate afterward
Take notes in the referee's words, then rate each competency against the same anchors your interviewers use. Rate alone, before you see the panel's scores, just as interviewers submit feedback before a debrief.
Keep the notes with the candidate record: a dated note of who you spoke to and what they said beats "references fine". The guide to documenting hiring decisions covers what that record should hold.
Consent and legal care
This section is general information, not legal advice. Rules on references and privacy differ by country, state and city, so check your process with employment counsel.
- Get the candidate's permission first. MSPB notes that a signed consent form strengthens the implied permission an applicant gives by applying. In the UK, Acas advises asking for references at the final stage, after a conditional offer, with the applicant's permission.
- Keep every question job related. The EEOC says questions that may reveal race, sex, national origin, disability, age, religion or ancestry should generally be avoided, and that employers may not ask about disability before an offer. Apply that to questions put to referees too.
- Take pay out of the script. New York City, for example, bars employers from asking people at an applicant's current or former employer about the applicant's pay history. Other places have similar rules.
- Check what changes when a vendor makes the calls. The FTC's employer guidance describes "investigative consumer reports", based on personal interviews about someone's character and reputation, which carry extra obligations under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, including written notice.
- Be consistent. Check references for every finalist at the same stage, not only for candidates someone has doubts about.
Backchannel references and their risks
A backchannel reference is a call to someone the candidate didn't name, such as a mutual connection. Hiring managers like them because the candidate didn't choose the source. The risks are real:
- You can expose the candidate's job search. Acas notes that approaching a current employer too early can make things difficult for the applicant.
- The information is unstructured. "I heard she was difficult" is not evidence, and you cannot rate it against a scorecard.
- It invites bias. Informal calls are where remarks about age, family or health slip in, and only some candidates get them.
There is a safer version. MSPB suggests asking each referee, at the end of the call, who else worked closely with the candidate, then getting the candidate's permission before contacting anyone new. You get a source the candidate didn't pick, under the same questions as everyone else.
References as a fraud check in remote hiring
Remote hiring gives reference checks a second job: confirming that the candidate's history is real, a problem our guide to candidate fraud in remote hiring covers in full. The weak point is that the candidate supplies the phone number.
The FBI's July 23, 2025 alert on North Korean IT workers advises employers to verify prior employment and education directly with the businesses and schools, rather than relying only on what the candidate provides. In practice:
- Find the company's main number or verified domain yourself, and reach the referee through it.
- Open each call by asking the referee's job title, employer and how they worked with the candidate, and check it against the resume.
- Ask the referee to describe the candidate's responsibilities. MSPB notes that a friend or fake reference will not be able to do this in detail.
One oddity is not proof. A cluster of mismatches is a reason for a direct, fair follow-up with the candidate.
Worked example: a customer success manager script
This script follows the customer success manager scorecard from our interview guide, targeting three competencies where a manager's long view adds most. Before the call, the candidate has signed consent and named two former managers and one peer, and the recruiter has confirmed each company's number independently.
Opening (3 minutes)
- "[Candidate] has given permission for this call. I ask the same questions about every finalist, and I'll take notes."
- "What was your job title, and how did you work with [Candidate], and for how long?"
- "In your own words, what was [Candidate] responsible for?"
Core questions (12 minutes)
| Competency | Question | Probe |
|---|---|---|
| Retention ownership | "Tell me about an account [Candidate] owned that was at risk of not renewing. What did they do?" | "What was the outcome, and what would you have liked them to do differently?" |
| Escalation handling | "Describe a time a customer escalated to you about something [Candidate] was handling." | "What had [Candidate] already done before it reached you?" |
| Cross-team follow-through | "Give me an example of [Candidate] needing product or support to fix something for a customer." | "How did they keep the customer and the internal team updated?" |
Close (5 minutes)
- "What support would help [Candidate] do their best work in the first 90 days?"
- "Who else worked closely with [Candidate] that I should speak to?" Contact them only with the candidate's permission.
- Never ask about pay, health, absences, age, family or life outside work.
After the call, rate each competency from 1 to 5 against the scorecard anchors, with two or three lines of evidence in the referee's words. "She's great with customers" with no example is no evidence, so record it that way rather than as a 3.
How this maps to HireRabbit.AI
In HireRabbit.AI, you can limit a person to one hiring stage, so whoever runs reference calls sees that round and nothing else. Moving a single candidate to a new stage requires a written reason, which keeps a record of why a finalist went forward or stopped after references. See how it fits together on the product page.